Journal Search Engine
Search Advanced Search Adode Reader(link)
Download PDF Export Citaion korean bibliography PMC previewer
ISSN : 1229-1153(Print)
ISSN : 2465-9223(Online)
Journal of Food Hygiene and Safety Vol.33 No.3 pp.157-161

Development of User-Friendly Modeling Software and Its Application in Processed Meat Products

Heeyoung Lee1, Panho Lee2, Soomin Lee1, Sejeong Kim1,3, Jeeyeon Lee1,3, Jimyeong Ha1,3, Yukyung Choi1,3, Hyemin Oh1,3, Yohan Yoon1,3*
1Risk Analysis Research Center, Sookmyung Women’s University, Seoul, Korea
2TNH, Seongnam, Korea
3Department of Food and Nutrition, Sookmyung Women’s University, Seoul, Korea
Correspondence to: Yohan Yoon, Department of Food and Nutrition, Sookmyung Women’s University, Seoul 04310, Korea Tel: 82-2-2077-7585, Fax:
April 13, 2018 May 10, 2018 May 31, 2018


The objective of this study was to develop software to predict the kinetic behavior and the probability of foodborne bacterial growth on processed meat products. It is designed for rapid application by non-specialists in predictive microbiology. The software, named Foodborne bacteria Animal product Modeling Equipment (FAME), was developed using Javascript and HTML. FAME consists of a kinetic model and a probabilistic model, and it can be used to predict bacterial growth pattern and probability. In addition, validation and editing of model equation are available in FAME. The data used by the software were constructed with 5,400 frankfurter samples for the kinetic model and 345,600 samples for the probabilistic model using a variety of combinations including atmospheric conditions, temperature, NaCl concentrations and NaNO2 concentrations. Using FAME, users can select the concentrations of NaCl and NaNO2 meat products as well as storage conditions (atmosphere and temperature). The software displays bacterial growth patterns and growth probabilities, which facilitate the determination of optimal safety conditions for meat products. FAME is useful in predicting bacterial kinetic behavior and growth probability, especially for quick application, and is designed for use by non-specialists in predictive microbiology.


    Predictive models have been used to predict kinetic behavior and to calculate the growth probability of foodborne pathogens under various conditions1,2). For kinetic modeling, a primary model and a secondary model need to be developed to estimate kinetic parameters of foodborne pathogens such as lag phase duration and growth rate. A primary model describes kinetic behavior over time, and a secondary model describes the effect of environmental factors on the kinetic parameters3,4). In addition, a probabilistic model has been used to estimate the probabilities of bacterial growth under a variety of factor-combinations3,5).

    Although many predictive models are developed, they are difficult for nonspecialists to understand, especially for industry applications. Thus, the applications of previously developed models have been limited. The advent of computer technology and associated advances in computational power have made it possible to perform complex mathematical calculations that would otherwise be too timeconsuming for useful applications in predictive microbiology 6). Hence, computer software has been developed to simplify the prediction of growth or inactivation of foodborne pathogens under various conditions. However, this type of software is not considered user-friendly for those who are not specialized in predictive modeling. Thus, although predictive models are useful in processing meat products, this technology is not used in the industry. In addition, even for experts in predictive microbiological modelling, the development of a predictive model is timeconsuming.

    Therefore, the objective of this study was to develop a user-friendly modeling software, which is equipped to handle both kinetic and probabilistic models, in order to predict bacterial growth and growth probability by simulating simple meat-product-related conditions.

    Materials and Methods

    Data collection

    All the data were collected from our previous research7-13). A kinetic model was constructed with 5,400 samples of frankfurters for Pseudomonas spp., Listeria monocytogenes and Salmonella, and probabilistic models was constructed with 345,600 samples in broth for L. monocytogenes, Staphylococcus aureus, and Salmonella.

    Mathematical base

    Kinetic models such as primary and secondary models can estimate kinetic parameters. Primary models describe the kinetic behavior of bacteria over time, and secondary models describe the effect of environmental factors on the kinetic parameters3,5). The primary model was based on a modified Gompertz model3,14), and the model equation was as follows:

    N t = A + C  × exp { exp [ B ( t-M ) ] } ,

    where Nt is the cell number at any time t, A is the lower asymptotic line of the growth curve as t decreases to zero, C is the difference between the upper asymptotic line of the growth curve and the lower asymptotic line, B is the relative growth rate at time M, and M is the time at which the growth rate is at a maximum (h). μmax, LPD, and Nmax can be calculated by the equations:

    μ max = BC/e  ( e=2.7182 ) ,

    LPD = M -  ( 1 / B ) ,  and

    N max = A + C.

    Development of predictive modeling software

    The predictive modeling software, named FAME (Foodborne bacteria Animal product Modeling Equipment), was developed for predicting bacterial growth on meat products. FAME can calculate bacterial concentrations and bacterial growth probabilities of meat product processing in advance. The software was programmed using Javascript and HTML, and the software was developed for two distinct model types, kinetic models and probabilistic models.

    In kinetic models, the cell counts of L. monocytogenes, Pseudomonas spp., and Salmonella spp., can be predicted by entering atmospheric conditions (aerobic or anaerobic), storage temperatures (0-40°C), NaNO2 concentrations (0 or 10 ppm), and NaCl concentrations (0-4.0%). In addition, a validation function was incorporated into FAME to compare experimental data and predicted bacterial concentrations.

    In probabilistic models, bacterial growth probability (L. monocytogenes, Salmonella spp., S. aureus) can be predicted based on atmospheric conditions (aerobic or anaerobic), temperatures (0-15°C), NaCl concentrations (0, 0.25, 0.50, 0.75, 1.00, 1.25, 1.50, or 1.75), NaNO2 concentrations (0- 150 ppm) and especially at 4°C, 7°C, 10°C, 12°C, and 15°C. The formulation for the validation of the predicted value with experimental data was incorporated into the software. In addition, in both the kinetic and the probabilistic models, all model equations can be edited by a user, and new model equations can be uploaded by a user.

    Application on meat products

    In the application of FAME, eight scenarios for Salmonella spp. on meat products according to atmospheric conditions, storage temperatures, and NaCl concentrations were compared using the kinetic model (Table 1). In addition, growth probabilities of Salmonella spp. were calculated, using the probabilistic model, based on the scenarios.

    Results and Discussion

    The user interface developed for FAME is shown Figs. 1- 3. In the kinetic model, the user can choose bacteria (Fig. 1(A)), and then select food atmospheric conditions (aerobic or anaerobic), NaNO2 concentrations, NaCl concentrations, assumed initial cell concentrations, maximum cell concentrations, and time intervals (Fig. 1(B)). Users can select ‘growth prediction’ to display the graph and value of predicted cell concentrations according to the database. In addition, if users want to validate their own laboratory data, users can input their experimental data by a simple copyand- paste from Microsoft® Excel into FAME. Then, Bf, Af, and RMSE values are calculated by comparing experimental data and predicted data. Fig. 2

    The probabilistic model also allows users to select the name of the bacteria (Fig. 2(A)), as well as variables such as packaging condition, growth probability (10%, 50%, and 90% interfaces), temperature, and NaCl concentration (Fig. 2(B)). When users click ‘growth probability prediction’, the graph of bacterial growth probability is displayed according to the strength of the probability, using blue (10% growth probability), red (50% growth probability), and/or yellow lines (90% growth probability). Users can estimate bacterial growth probability under selected environmental conditions, and the data can be used for determining the best conditions for the safety of meat products.

    If users want to change the calculating equation, they can click the ‘setting’ button to edit, and users also can add new equations from their own data (Fig. 3). When editing an equation or adding a new equation, users can immediately confirm the growth prediction graph and cell concentration under certain conditions for both kinetic and probabilistic models.

    Using FAME software, users can predict bacterial concentrations in advance and can thus, determine the best conditions for the safety of meat products with specific bacterial concentrations as set in FAME. Table 1 provides data on simple scenarios for the application of FAME for meat products. When users select environmental conditions based on these scenarios, the bacterial growth curve and concentrations according to time are presented. According to the scenarios, the times for 1 Log CFU/g growth on meat products, relative to initial concentrations, are predicted by the kinetic model as 288 h, 54 h, 160 h, 38 h, 510 h, 35 h, 165 h, and 20 h, respectively. Comparing scenarios 1 and 2, when the temperature is increased from 7°C to 15°C, time for 1 Log CFU/g Salmonella spp. growth is decreased from 288 h to 54 h in an anaerobic atmosphere. Also, when NaCl concentrations decreased 1.5% to 0.5%, time for 1 Log CFU/g Salmonella spp. growth is decreased from 288 h to 160 h at 7°C (scenarios 1 and 3), and from 54 h to 38 h at 15°C in an anaerobic atmosphere (scenarios 2 and 4). In addition, when meat products were packaged aerobically, time for 1 Log CFU/g Salmonella spp. growth is increased, compared to an aerobic packaging (scenarios 5-8). With these results, users can predict bacterial growth and determine appropriate plans for food safety for meat products.


    In conclusion, FAME can be useful in the meat processing industry for food safety, especially in terms of its rapid application. In addition, because of its user-friendly interface, even non specialists in predictive modeling can use the software to predict both bacterial concentrations from kinetic models and growth probabilities from probabilistic models.


    This work was carried out with the support of “Cooperative Research Program for Agriculture Science & Technology Development (Project No. PJ009237)”, Rural Development Administration, Republic of Korea.



    Kinetic model part in FAME. A user selects (A) the name of bacteria and (B) conditions such as atmospheric condition, temperature, NaCl concentration, NaNO2 concentration, initial and maximum cell concentration, and time interval. This is followed by (C) entering observed data and (D) the resulting data validation.


    Probabilistic modeling in FAME. A user selects (A) bacteria and (B) conditions such as packaging condition, growth probability (10, 50, 90% interface), temperature and NaCl concentration.


    Editing (A) kinetic and (B) probabilistic models in FAME.


    Scenarios for application on meat products, and calculated bacterial concentrations and growth probabilities based on the scenarios using FAME


    1. CorollerL. GuerrotV. HuchetV. Le MarcY. MafartP. SohierD. ThuaultD. Modelling the influence of single acid and mixture on bacterial growth. Int. J. Food Microbiol.2005100, 167-178
    2. Van ImpeJ.F. PoschetF. GeeraerdA.H. VereeckenK.M. Towards a novel class of predictive microbial growth models. Int. J. Food Microbiol.2005100, 97-105
    3. KoutsoumanisK.P. KendallP.A. SofosJ.N. Modeling the boundaries of growth of Salmonella Typhimurium in broth as a function of temperature, water activity, and pH. J. Food Prot.200467, 53-59
    4. LeeS. LeeH. LeeJ.Y. SkandamisP. ParkB.Y. OhM.H. YoonY. Mathematical models to predict kinetic behavior and growth probabilities of Listeria monocytogenes on pork skin at constant and dynamic temperatures. J. Food Prot.201376, 1868-1872
    5. RatkowskyD.A. RossT. Modelling the bacterial growth/ no growth interface. Lett. Appl. Microbiol.199520, 29-33
    6. McKellarR.C. LuX. Modeling microbial responses in food.In: Software programs to increase the utility of predictive microbiology information, Ed. Tamplin et al. CRC press233-242. ISBN 0-8493-1237-X (2004).2004
    7. GwakE. OhM.H. ParkB.Y. LeeH. LeeS. HaJ. LeeJ. KimS. ChoiK.H. YoonY. Probabilistic models to predict Listeria monocytogenes growth at low concentrations of NaNO2 and NaCl in frankfurters. Korean J. Food Sci. Anim. Resour.201535, 815-823
    8. GwakE. LeeH. OhM.H. ParkB.Y. HaJ. LeeJ. KimS. YoonY. Evalation of Salmonella growth at low NaNO2 and NaCl in processed meat products using probabilistic model. Asian-Australas. J. Anim. Sci.201629, 1013-1021
    9. HaJ. GwakE. OhM.H. ParkB.Y. LeeJ. KimS. LeeH. LeeS. YoonY. Kinetic behavior of Salmonella on low NaNO2 sausage during aerobic and vacuum storage. Korean J. Food Sci. Anim. Resour.201636, 262-266
    10. LeeH. GwakE. LeeS. KimS. LeeJ. HaJ. OhM.H. ParkB.Y. YangM. ChoiK.H. YoonY. Model to predict growth/no growth interfaces of Enterococcus as a function of NaCl and NaNO2. J. Food Saf.201636, 537-547
    11. LeeJ. GwakE. HaJ. KimS. LeeS. LeeH. OhM.H. ParkB.M. OhN.S. ChoiK.H. YoonY. Mathematical model for predicting the growth probability of Staphylococcus aureus in combinations of NaCl and NaNO2 under aerobic or evacuated storage conditions. Korean J. Food Sci. Anim. Resour.201636, 752-759
    12. LeeJ. GwakE. LeeH. HaJ. LeeS. KimS. OhM.H. ParkB.Y. ChoiK.H. YoonY. Effects of NaNO2 and NaCl concentrations on Listeria monocytogenes growth in emulsion- type sausage. Asian-Australas. J. Anim. Sci.201730, 432-438
    13. LeeS. LeeH. KimS. GwakE. OhM.H. ParkB.M. KimJ.S. ChoiK.S. YoonY. Probabilistic models to describe the effect of NaNO2 in combination with NaCl on the growth inhibition of Lactobacillus in frankfurters. Meat Sci.2015110, 302-309
    14. GibsonA.M. BratchellN. RobertsT.A. The effect of sodium chloride and temperature on the rate and extent of growth of Clostridium botulinum type A in pasteurized pork slurry. J. Appl. Bacteriol.198762, 479-490
    15. YoonH. LeeJ.Y. SukH.J. LeeS. LeeH. LeeS. YoonY. Modeling to Predict growth/no growth boundaries and kinetic behavior of Salmonella on cutting board surfaces. J. Food Prot.201275, 2116-2121